2005 - Tressie Knowlton

2006 - Tara Spencer

2004 - Cassidy Reid Kahoe

2003 - Christy Spurlock Draper

2002 - Addie Knowlton

2001 - Allison Munger Salo

2000 - Tara Graham Rowe

1999 - Aubrey Williams Hill

1998 - Aspen Emmett

1997 - Stacy Reid Basinger

1996 - Sara Boensch Collins

1995 - Paulette Woods O'Hotto

1994 - Susan Boensch Meyer

1993 - Melissa King McEndaffer

1992 - Terri Lynn Bunker Svendsen

1991 - Ginger Greene

1990 - Lori Shalberg

1989 - Kimber Greene

1988 - Mandy Wheatley Wolfe

1987 - Kellei Dilka Lambert Brandon

1986 - Kris Wilder Hall

1985 - Taleen Jenkins Vick

1984 - Kym Cooper Radosta

1983 - Vanette Ruzanski Benesch

1982 - Jill Lovelace Williams

1981 - Kimberley Nogel Mazza

1980 - Kathy Martin Colletti

1979 - Debbie Pech Ritch

1978 - Barbara Seitz Williams

1977 - Almabeth Carroll Kaess

1976 - Bobbie Jo Etter Jacquelin

1975 - Vicki Hallmark Hughes

1974 - Janine Hiatt Walter

1973 - DeAnna Swetzig

1972 - Yvonne Ann Winter Billingsley

1971 - Gail Hughes Anderson

1970 - Janet Donley Spanier

1968 - Kathleen Flinn

1967 - Jerry Bond Draper

1966 - Jo Beth Smith Steward

1965 - Kay Popino Baker

(Competed at the Miss Rodeo America Pagent due to Kathy Dalton Hodgson's injuries.)

1965 - Kathy Dalton Hodgson

1964 - Sherry Boyer Watts

1963 - Letha Sue Guilliams Israel

1962 - Margie Mowry Woodard

1961 - Rosemary Larson

1960 - Marie Mass Gatlin

1959 - Sandra Craig

1958 - Revae Milligan Woodworth

1957 - Donna Thomas Parrish

1956 - Elaine Ward Peterson Bixby